The Virgin Mother’s been called some unusual things: I’ve heard her likened to the Egyptian goddess Isis. I’ve read comparisons of her to the Greek maiden Leda (both, the comparison goes, conceived after a divine encounter).

I suppose I expected something just as startling or subversive in a new short book by Colm Toibin, “The Testament of Mary,” published by Scribner this month.

In a way, this is just what happened – although not in the way that I expected.

Toibin gives us a portrait of the mother of Jesus in her heartbroken old age: living in Ephesus, visited (and harassed) by the Gospel writers who want her to corroborate the story of Jesus that they’re writing. One of them scowls at her “when the story I tell him does not stretch to whatever limits he has ordained.”

What does she think of her son’s disciples?

They’re nothing but “a group of misfits, who were only children like himself, or men without fathers, or men who could not look a woman in the eye.”

This book started as a dramatic monologue performed before Dublin audiences, and all I could think was: Well, I wonder what people in the world’s most Catholic nation think of this!

After all, Mary’s not the figure of the Pieta, holding the body of her son after he is taken off the cross: She flees, terrified for her life.  There are many more provocative revelations — but I won’t spoil them — all rendered in Toibin’s characteristically beautiful, lyrical prose.

In the end, Toibin gives us a Mary who isn’t Isis, or Leda. She’s not a figure surrounded by stained-glass or stretching across the ceiling of countless church domes. Toibin’s testament presents us with someone far more powerful and easier to understand: A mother. Toibin’s Mary is human, all too human.


  1. Haven’t read this particular book by Tóibín yet, although I’ve read several of his others, (have you read his first, The South? super) he is brilliant, in fact I think he’s our finest living writer here in Ireland. Nice review, nice piece. I’ll visit again, and thank you very much for your visit and kind comments earlier. Respects from Dublin – Arran.

  2. I agree, Toibin’s superb. I’ve actually noticed that his new book on the Virgin Mary is angering some very extreme religious critics: I’ve read some posts elsewhere that condemn it. If only people would move past their fears, they’d see how beautiful it is. thanks also for your feedback.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s